| |
| "HEALTH:
Poisoned Lives: the Price Of Tobacco Farming " |
| |
| By Marwaan Macan-Markar |
MEXICO CITY - For the world's anti-tobacco movement,
a small town in southern Brazil has become a symbol
of a silent tragedy unfolding among communities which
have turned to tobacco farming for a livelihood.
What has contributed to such symbolism is the ''very
high rate of suicides'' in that town, Venancio Aires,
in the state of Rio Grande do Sul, says Angela Cordiero,
an agronomist and a Brazilian activist in the movement.
While the national average in Brazil has been three
suicides per 100,000 people, in Venancio Aires it
is seven times higher - 21 suicides per 100,000 inhabitants.
For Cordeiro, the suicide rate in Venancio Aires can
be traced to the ''dangerous pesticides'' used by
the tobacco farmers in that area.
''The organophosphate pesticides that farmers use
in the tobacco fields have chemicals known to affect
the neurological system. They often get depressed
after exposure and try to kill themselves,'' she adds.
This diagnosis, in fact, has been confirmed by researchers
at the Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul. Studies
have revealed that a majority of those who committed
suicide in Venancio Aires were farmers, and they had
killed themselves during the months when organophosphate
pesticides were used extensively in the tobacco fields.
For the tobacco-control movement, such a disturbing
phenomenon is only one of a litany of problems that
has been plaguing those who work on tobacco farms.
In this country, for instance, the plight of the Huichol
Indians working in the tobacco fields in the western
state of Nayarit has become a cause for concern.
Says Patricia Diaz-Romo, a Mexican anti-tobacco activist,
the most glaring as been the impact of pesticide poisoning
on the pregnant Huichol Indian women who have worked
in the fields.
''They give birth to deformed children, some who have
no genitalia and die within days of being born, some
who have no limbs,'' she reveals.
And during the 11th World Conference on Health Or
Tobacco held early this month in Chicago, activists
drew attention to such realities in their effort to
expose the health hazards faced by tobacco farmers.
According to Dr. Joshua Sharfstein, a physician at
the Boston University School of Medicine, the poisoned
lives of tobacco farmers has received little attention
from governments, due to ''very few knowing the dangers
of harvesting tobacco.''
''When used properly, some of the pesticides can cause
respiratory irritation, pose a danger to pregnant
women and contribute to cancer over many years,''
observes Sharfstein, who has researched the health
implications and national regulation of tobacco pesticides.
But, he remarks, ''when used indiscriminately or improperly,
some of the pesticides can cause nerve damage, troubled
breathing and death.''
For the World Health Organisation (WHO), the scarcity
of attention to the health hazards of tobacco farmers
reflects the larger global picture regards occupational
health problems. A WHO study points out, for instance,
that 'the evaluation of the global burden of occupational
diseases and injuries is difficult. Reliable information
for most developing countries is scarce.
'' This stems from the ''serious limitations in the
diagnosis of occupational illnesses and in the reporting
systems.
'' Referring to Latin America, for example, the WHO
reveals that only between one and four percent of
all occupational diseases are reported.
Says Cordeiro, there is a desperate need to change
this culture of silence. ''A surveillance system has
to be established in Latin America, Africa and Asia
to monitor the impact of pesticides on tobacco farmers
and their families.
'' Tobacco is grown in more than 100 countries, including
about 80 developing nations, states a 512-page report
released during this month's conference. And in recent
decades, it adds, the growth in world tobacco production
has multiplied significantly in low- and middle-income
countries.
''Between 1975 and 1998, production in developed countries
fell by 31 percent, while production in developing
countries rose by 128 percent,'' note the authors
of the report, 'Tobacco Control in Developing Countries,'
a joint publication of the WHO and the World Bank.
The reason for that stems from the type of crop tobacco
is. It is labour intensive and has the ''ability to
generate dependable cash flows for poor small farmers''.
On most tobacco farms, the demand is high for seasonal
labour for ''transplanting young plants from seedbeds
or greenhouses to fields, and for removing tops when
plants begin to flower.
'' According to tobacco-industry estimates, this has
meant some 33 million people being employed worldwide
in tobacco fields.
In a country like China, for instance, which tops
the current list of tobacco-growing countries, some
15 million people work on tobacco fields. For the
London-based Panos Institute, however, such high employment
figures have come with a price, given that ''tobacco
needs heavy applications of pesticides.'' And it accuses
the tobacco industry of ''rarely publishing'' the
figures stemming from pesticide poisoning, both of
the farmers working in the fields and of nearby communities.
According to the United States-based Pesticide Action
Network (PAN), the manner in which tobacco companies
''exert a great deal of control over the farmers''
cannot be ignored. In Brazil, for instance, ''the
company determines the size of the area to be sown
and the amount of fertilisers and pesticides to be
used,'' it declares. And to ensure that farmers are
following company guidelines, such as the required
use of pesticides and fertilisers, ''company inspectors
visit the fields regularly.
'' Studies done by the Pan American Health Organisation
(PAHO) state that ''occupational exposure is probably
one of the most important to tobacco farmers, since
they and their families are exposed constantly to
a large amount and variety of pesticides.
'' During the tobacco crop cycle, furthermore, PAHO
estimates that anywhere between 30 to 60 kilograms
of pesticides per hectare are used. In addition, there
is exposure during ''contact with raw materials, storage
and transportation'' of the pesticides.
What is more, reveals the PAHO, not only adults face
such hazardous situations during work, but children,
too. In Brazil, for instance, there are over 1 million
children working on tobacco farms ''who are exposed
to huge mounts of pesticides.'' Unfortunately, admits
the PAHO, ''few health professionals are prepared
to draw a causal nexus between symptoms of acute or
chronic intoxication and pesticide exposure."
'For Sharfstein, that has led to troubling consequences,
since the tobacco farmers need to have ''regular access
to doctors and nurses to address their) health problems
- both by means of treatment and prevention - that
result from the work on tobacco farms.''
And for Diaz-Romo and Cordeiro, the need to secure
such medical care and attention for the tobacco farmers
has become a priority, requiring greater pressure
from the anti-tobacco movement to expose the health
hazards of tobacco cultivation.
(END/IPS/HE/mmm/da/00)
More information available at: http://www.panna.org/panna
Pesticide Action Network
|