 |
|
|
Mapuches Return to Benetton-Held Land |
|
By Marcela Valente*
Six
indigenous families are returning to live on a plot of land that
the Italian clothing company Benetton owns in the Patagonia region.
Benetton has not yet decided what, if any, legal action it will
take.
BUENOS AIRES, Feb 24 (Tierramérica) - Mapuches
in the southern Argentine region of Patagonia, who in 2002 led a
land conflict against the Italian textile group Benetton, have returned
to occupy land belonging to the firm, reclaiming their ancestral
rights.
"This is not a protest, nor is it a clandestine action. We don't
intend to be owners, but rather live as a community in our territory,"
Mauro Millán told Tierramérica. He was acting as spokesman for the
25 Mapuches who since Feb. 14 have occupied the Santa Rosa farm
in the southern province of Chubut in Patagonia.
There are six families building homes there, near the site from
which they were expelled five years ago.
Santa Rosa, covering 534 hectares, is on the Leleque ranch. In 1991,
Benetton acquired the Compañía de Tierras Sud Argentino (CTSA),
dedicated to agricultural production, which included Leleque and
other ranches in the province.
In one section of the ranch, Benetton opened the Leleque Museum
in homage to the region's indigenous peoples and pioneers. But the
Mapuches say they do not want to see themselves portrayed as "trophies
of one culture that destroys what is different", and they claim
their right to the land.
The attorney general's office of Esquel, the closest city, last
week filed a claim of misappropriation. But spokespersons from the
firm told Tierramérica it was a government claim. The company has
not yet determined a legal course, because it considered the case
a concluded issue.
The new community says the territory belongs to them since before
the CTSA was created and that the seizure comes from that period.
"This for us is a return to a common territory of the Mapuches.
There are old cemeteries of ours there," said Millán.
"Since our land was usurped, the landowners have enjoyed impunity,
protection of private property. Is the snow private? Is the wind,
is the river private?" asks a proclamation signed by the Mapuches,
who say they will never give up this land.
The CTSA company was founded in 1889 when the Argentine government
ceded land to 10 British citizens, with 90,000 hectares going to
each one, bypassing the Mapuche communities who lived there, and
who ended up as laborers on the new ranches, Leleque among them.
"From the world view of the Mapuche they have rights. The problem
is that the land was divided more than a century ago amongst individuals.
In other words, it's not government land," Gonzalo Sánchez, author
of the book "La Patagonia Vendida" (Patagonia for Sale).
With the purchase of CTSA, Benetton then had 970,000 hectares in
Patagonia, and is the top private landowners in Argentina. In 2002,
the Mapuches Atilio Curiñanco, Rosa Nahuelquir and their children
occupied Santa Rosa, convinced that it was government-held land.
But the company, which used the land for forestry, denounced the
invasion, and the police violently removed the Mapuches, destroying
their humble home and their crops, and dispersing their livestock.
The Indians faced criminal charges for misappropriation and a civil
case arising from the land conflict. In the legal process the judge
ruled lack of blame for the accused, but on the civil side resolved
that the land belonged to Benetton.
"Every time they bring native peoples like us into the supposed
legal context it's to our detriment, but we have arguments to support
us," said Millán.
Since the expulsion, actions took Curiñanco and Nahuelquir to Italy
in 2004, accompanied by Adolfo Pérez Esquivel, the Argentine Nobel
Peace laureate (1980), who organized an interview with Luciano Benetton.
After that tense meeting in Rome, the business executive promised
to look for a solution to the conflict.
Months later, Benetton offered the Chubut provincial government
7,500 hectares in Piedra Parada, located 200 km from the Leleque
ranch. The idea was to set aside the land for the Mapuche families
to farm, but the offer was rejected.
"The Chubut government determined that they were unproductive lands,"
said Paula Vázquez, of the international consultancy Burson Masteller,
hired by CTSA for public relations. "It's true that it would need
investment, but the land could be forested and used for raising
sheep," she told Tierramérica.
Curiñanco and Nahuelquir are back, with other families from their
community, camping on the land they believe was their ancestors'.
Benetton offered to make a donation. "But neither is it our responsibility
to recognize ancestral rights over lands acquired from a private
company," said the spokesperson.
According to Millán, "the donation was to clean up Benetton's image,
but they never proposed anything to us directly. Piedra Parada is
rich in archeological sites, a wonderful and fertile place, but
it only ended up expanding the company's immense holdings."
The Chubut government, from which the Mapuches are demanding inclusive
policies, has washed its hands of the matter. "We're not intervening
because we are not involved. It's a conflict with a private company,"
an official who requested anonymity told Tierramérica.
* Marcela Valente is an IPS correspondent. |
